I Couldn't Agree More
Gramaphone's review of one of the latest opera "collections":
Perhaps, in such collections as this, it is best to forget about the aria’s context and simply take each item as it comes; but that is not always possible, as (for example) “Porgi, amor� cannot suddenly be disassociated from the Countess, and it is a piece of surreal effrontery to have her finish and Blonde from Die Entfuhrung come cavorting in, vivace e presto, with “Welche Wonne, welche Lust�. Then when she skips off, Konstanze arrives – same opera, same voice, different character. It won’t quite do. And then why, one wonders, is the second of Konstanze’s arias, “Ach, ich liebte�, not allowed to follow the first, as Zerlina’s is?
Well put! DG take heed the order does matter! Actually, to be completely honest, let's get rid of the "greatest opera arias of all time" disks completely, shall we?
Posted by phooeyhoo at
4:31 PM
|
Comments (0)
| Opera!